Hotel restaurants can be hit or miss, but our meal at Reign
was a definite hit. As part of the Toronto Life Insider series, the tasting
menu ($150/person) treated us to a canape and four-course dinner, complete
with wine pairings.
The restaurant was rebuilt and reopened in 2019, but we all
know what happened around that time. Since then, Reign seems to have found its
groove and is now operating like a well-oiled machine. After locating the
restaurant tucked into a corner of the hotel lobby, I was warmly greeted and
whisked into the separate dining area for the evening. Before I could even
settle in, a glass of nicely chilled prosecco was in hand, followed shortly by
a steak tartare canape.
Served on a piece of lightly toasted brioche, the tartare
had a nice balance of flavours while allowing the beef to remain the star. It
didn't need a mountain of garnishes or sauces… just a well-executed bite that
whetted my appetite for the meal ahead.
Before dinner, we were welcomed in groups for a tour of the
hotel's main-floor kitchen. Massive barely begins to describe it. The kitchen
stretched from one side of the hotel to the other, with separate areas serving
the different restaurants and in-room dining operations.
And that wasn't even the whole operation! We learned that
the Royal York has another kitchen on a separate floor dedicated to catering.
Considering the hotel serves over a million meals and 250,000 staff meals
annually, I suppose a regular-sized kitchen simply wouldn't cut it. The brigade
includes 120 cooks, ten managers, an executive sous chef, and an executive
chef. Imagine the logistics of organizing a team meeting with that many people.
That evening's menu was designed by Executive Chef Roland
Torok-Ducharme. He might look 25, but he's worked in several countries, often
at Michelin-starred restaurants, before coming home to Toronto to lead Reign's
kitchen. The menu was designed to showcase both his culinary journey and his
current home at Reign.
Bread service kicked things off with a duck fat and paprika brioche. Chef Roland explained that it was a nod to his Hungarian roots, inspired by kattancs, a milk bread his mother used to make. His version incorporated a generous swirl of paprika and toasted sunflower seeds into the dough, adding flavour and a little texture to the otherwise soft bread. A coating of duck fat gave it a glossy finish, while paprika whipped butter provided even more flavour. It was a solid start, though a little more salt in the butter would have made the flavours pop even more.
You can rarely go wrong with butter-poached Nova Scotia
lobster, a dish inspired by Chef Roland's time at Lasserre in Paris. The
lobster was perfectly poached, just cooked through and still tender, then
served with a red wine and peach bisque. My only complaint? No spoon was
provided, and I would have loved to dig further into that sauce.
From what I could soak up with a piece of bread, it leaned
more towards a sauce than a traditional bisque. The red wine flavour was also
quite pronounced, so a spoonful might have been a little intense on its own.
Perhaps the idea was to enjoy it in smaller quantities alongside the lobster.
Next up was the roasted seabass, which was cooked
spot-on, remaining tender and flaky. I could almost hear Gordon Ramsay
declaring it delicious as he sampled it at Pétrus, the restaurant that inspired
this course. The sauce au vin jaune was a silky, buttery cream sauce
infused with saffron. Rich, yes, but not so heavy that it overpowered the fish.
The accompaniments brought plenty of variety to the plate:
soft braised leeks, firmer glazed salsify, silky cauliflower purée, and
hazelnuts for crunch. Chef Roland mentioned that he likes adding nuts to dishes
for textural contrast. I'm usually not a fan of nuts thrown into a dish
unnecessarily, but here, the crunch against the smooth purée worked
surprisingly well.
Steakhouses are making a comeback in Toronto, and the dry-aged
Ontario beef put Reign's own spin on the trend. Rather than leaning
entirely into the usual North American steakhouse approach, Chef Roland's
French techniques came through in the preparation.
Sourced from Creekside Farms, the beef was presented two
ways. The dry-aged cut was seared with a lovely peppery crust that let the
flavour of the meat shine through, and it was cooked just right. The short rib,
meanwhile, was braised, glazed, and served with braised Lyonnaise onions.
Honestly, I could have happily eaten a whole plate of that short rib alone.
On the side was a thin layer of potato gratin. It was a
little too soft for my liking, and a more substantial golden crust would have
made it much better. A bone marrow royale, which tasted like a richer, more
indulgent aioli, rounded things out. This was definitely the heavier course of
the evening, with butter making its presence known across several components.
Executive Pastry Chef Kapila Amaratunga was responsible for
the final course, le feuilleté. With so many elements on the
plate, I needed a moment to decide where to start. Naturally, I went straight
for the caramelized puff pastry, layered with chocolate and white chocolate
creams, before adding some toasted croissant ice cream to the mix.
I saved the Valrhona Manjari chocolate crémeux for
last, expecting an intense chocolate hit. Surprisingly, it was fairly
restrained in sweetness and didn't overwhelm with chocolate flavour, perhaps
thanks to the use of 64% chocolate. Chocolate popping candy scattered on top
was a fun idea, though the effect was rather subtle unless you let it melt on
your tongue. A sprinkling of cocoa nibs might have delivered a more immediate
crunch and contrast.
Service throughout the evening was excellent, as you'd
expect from a restaurant of this calibre. Even better, unlike some of the other
Toronto Life Insider dinners we've attended, this one started on time and
wrapped up within two hours. That meant we could enjoy a proper multi-course
dinner without sacrificing the rest of our weeknight.
There are perks to dining at a hotel restaurant, especially one with the resources of the Royal York behind it. Reign delivered polished service, a kitchen with serious scale, and a menu that reflected Chef Roland's international experience without losing sight of the ingredients. Not every element was perfect, but the meal was enjoyable from start to finish. If you're looking for a special-occasion dinner in downtown Toronto, Reign is worth considering, particularly if you appreciate French technique and a well-paced menu.
Address: 100 Front Street West (in Fairmont Royal York)
____________________________
Gastro World's Grading System
- Anything under 5 - I really disliked and will never go back
- 6 - decent restaurant but I likely won't return
- 7 - decent restaurant and I will likely return
- 8 - great restaurant that I'd be happy to recommend
- 9 - fantastic restaurant that I would love to visit regularly and highly recommend
- 10 - absolute perfection!
Is That It? I Want More!
Other Gastro World posts similar to this:










